Skip to main content

Last updated:

As an Amazon Associate, OffGrid Filters earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are subject to change. Learn about our affiliate policy.

Water Filter Cost Analysis: True Cost of Ownership

The price on the box is only the beginning. Replacement filters, water waste, electricity, and maintenance all contribute to the true cost of owning a water filter. We calculated the 1-year and 5-year total cost of ownership for every major filter type in our catalog — from budget pitchers to premium RO systems — so you can make a genuinely informed decision about where your money goes.

Water filter cost of ownership analysis

The Cost Components Most People Miss

Every water filter has four cost components. Most buyers only consider the first one:

  1. Purchase price: The upfront cost of the filter system itself.
  2. Replacement filters: The ongoing cartridge cost. This is almost always the largest expense over time.
  3. Water waste: RO systems produce wastewater. At average US water rates (~$0.004 per gallon), this adds $10-$30 per year.
  4. Electricity: Tankless RO and countertop systems need power. Adds $5-$15 per year.

Our analysis assumes a family of 4 consuming approximately 3 gallons of filtered water per day (1,095 gallons per year). Adjust proportionally for your household.

Pro Tip
The single biggest money-saving move in water filtration is switching from bottled water to any filter. A family of 4 buying bottled water spends $800-$2,200 per year. Even the most expensive filter system on this page costs less than $200 per year to operate.

Pitcher Filter Systems: Cost Breakdown

Amazon Basics Pitcher + Amazon Basics Enhanced Filters

The budget champion.

  • Pitcher: Under $25
  • Replacement filters: Under $25 for 3-pack ($3.50 each, 40 gallons per filter)
  • Filters needed per year (family of 4): ~27 filters (1,095 gallons / 40 gallons per filter)
  • Annual filter cost: ~$95
  • Year 1 total: ~$119
  • 5-year total: ~$498
  • Cost per gallon: ~$0.09

Brita UltraMax + Brita Standard Filters

The most popular option.

  • Dispenser: $25–$50
  • Replacement filters: Under $25 for 3-pack ($6.00 each, 40 gallons per filter)
  • Filters needed per year: ~27 filters
  • Annual filter cost: ~$162
  • Year 1 total: ~$197
  • 5-year total: ~$845
  • Cost per gallon: ~$0.15

Brita UltraMax + Brita Elite Filters

The smart upgrade — cheaper per gallon than Standard.

  • Dispenser: $25–$50
  • Replacement filters: $25–$50 for 2-pack ($14.89 each, 120 gallons per filter)
  • Filters needed per year: ~9 filters (1,095 / 120)
  • Annual filter cost: ~$134
  • Year 1 total: ~$169
  • 5-year total: ~$705
  • Cost per gallon: ~$0.12

ZeroWater Pitcher + 5-Stage Filters

The premium pitcher — with a painful cost surprise.

  • Pitcher: ~$35 (varies by model)
  • Replacement filters: $50–$100 for 4-pack ($15.00 each, ~20 gallons per filter at average TDS)
  • Filters needed per year: ~55 filters (1,095 / 20)
  • Annual filter cost: ~$825
  • Year 1 total: ~$860
  • 5-year total: ~$4,160
  • Cost per gallon: ~$0.75

ZeroWater delivers 0-TDS purity but at a staggering annual cost. In high-TDS areas (300+ ppm), filters may last only 15 gallons, pushing costs even higher. For reference, bottled water costs roughly $0.50-$2.00 per gallon. ZeroWater can approach or exceed the cost of many bottled water brands.

Pro Tip
The Brita Elite is one of the best value secrets in water filtration. Despite costing $14.89 per filter vs $6 for Brita Standard, the Elite's 120-gallon capacity means it costs less per gallon ($0.12 vs $0.15) and adds NSF 53/401 certifications (lead, pharmaceuticals) that Standard lacks. It is both cheaper and better long-term.

Under-Sink RO Systems: Cost Breakdown

iSpring RCC7AK (75 GPD, Tank-Based)

The best overall value for serious filtration.

  • System: $100–$250
  • Annual filter replacement: ~$50-$60 (3 pre-filters at $10 each, 1 post-carbon at $12, 1 remineralization at $8)
  • RO membrane replacement: ~$25 every 2.5 years ($10/year amortized)
  • Water waste cost: ~$13/year (1:3 ratio = 3,285 gallons waste at $0.004/gallon)
  • Electricity: $0 (uses water pressure only)
  • Year 1 total: ~$272
  • 5-year total: ~$558
  • Cost per gallon: ~$0.10

The iSpring's total cost of ownership over 5 years is lower than the Brita UltraMax with Standard filters — while providing dramatically better filtration (6-stage RO vs. basic carbon).

Waterdrop G3P600 (600 GPD, Tankless)

The premium choice with higher ongoing costs.

  • System: $250–$500
  • Annual filter replacement: ~$80-$100 (CF filter every 6 months ~$30, MRO every 12 months ~$50, CB every 24 months ~$20/year amortized)
  • Water waste cost: ~$9/year (2:1 ratio = 2,190 gallons waste at $0.004/gallon)
  • Electricity: ~$10/year (pump requires power)
  • Year 1 total: ~$528
  • 5-year total: ~$923
  • Cost per gallon: ~$0.17

The Waterdrop G3P600 costs more per gallon than the iSpring, but you are paying for tankless on-demand water, smart TDS monitoring, and space savings. Whether the premium is worth it depends on your priorities.

Countertop RO Systems: Cost Breakdown

Bluevua RO100ROPOT-UV

  • System: $250–$500
  • Annual filter replacement: ~$70-$90 (RO membrane every 12 months, other filters every 6 months)
  • Water waste cost: ~$9/year (2:1 ratio)
  • Electricity: ~$8/year
  • Year 1 total: ~$404
  • 5-year total: ~$751
  • Cost per gallon: ~$0.14

Bluevua RO100ROPOT-Lite UV

  • System: $219.00
  • Annual filter replacement: ~$65-$85
  • Water waste cost: ~$13/year (3:1 ratio)
  • Electricity: ~$8/year
  • Year 1 total: ~$305
  • 5-year total: ~$649
  • Cost per gallon: ~$0.12

The Lite UV offers the best value in countertop RO, combining no-install convenience with a competitive per-gallon cost.

Commercial-Grade Under-Sink: Cost Breakdown

Pentair Everpure H-1200 (Cartridge Replacements)

  • Cartridges: $250–$500 (requires existing filter head)
  • Replacement frequency: Every 12 months (1,000 gallons)
  • Water waste: $0 (not RO)
  • Electricity: $0
  • Year 1 total: ~$390 (cartridges only; filter head adds ~$100-$150 first time)
  • 5-year total: ~$2,050 (including initial system setup)
  • Cost per gallon: ~$0.37

The Pentair Everpure is the most expensive per-gallon option, but delivers commercial restaurant-grade filtration quality. It is best suited for those who prioritize absolute taste quality and have the budget to support it.

Refrigerator Filters: Cost Breakdown

OEM Route (GE XWFE or everydrop Filter 1)

Aftermarket Route (AQUACREST 3-Pack)

The aftermarket savings are dramatic, but you give up NSF 53/401 certification (lead, pharmaceuticals). If your main concern is taste, aftermarket is fine. If you need contaminant reduction, stick with OEM.

Pro Tip
If you use a refrigerator filter for ice and cold water only (not primary drinking water), the aftermarket route is a smart move. Pair it with an under-sink filter at the kitchen faucet for serious drinking water filtration. This hybrid approach maximizes filtration where it matters while minimizing cost where it does not.

The Bottled Water Comparison

For perspective, here is what bottled water costs a family of 4 consuming 3 gallons per day:

  • Budget store brand (24-pack, $4): ~$600/year
  • Mid-range brand (24-pack, $6): ~$900/year
  • Premium brand (24-pack, $10): ~$1,500/year
  • 5-gallon delivery service: ~$400-$700/year

Every single filter system in our analysis — even the expensive ZeroWater — is cheaper than mid-range bottled water in year two. And unlike bottled water, you eliminate plastic waste, microplastic ingestion from bottles, and the hassle of buying and carrying heavy packs.

5-Year Cost Comparison Summary

Here is every system ranked by total 5-year cost of ownership for a family of 4:

  1. Amazon Basics pitcher + Amazon Basics filters: ~$498 ($0.09/gallon) — Best budget value
  2. iSpring RCC7AK under-sink RO: ~$558 ($0.10/gallon) — Best overall value for serious filtration
  3. Bluevua Lite UV countertop RO: ~$649 ($0.12/gallon) — Best no-install RO value
  4. Brita UltraMax + Elite filters: ~$705 ($0.12/gallon) — Best premium pitcher
  5. Bluevua RO100ROPOT-UV countertop: ~$751 ($0.14/gallon) — Best premium countertop
  6. Brita UltraMax + Standard filters: ~$845 ($0.15/gallon) — Most popular (but not most economical)
  7. Waterdrop G3P600 tankless RO: ~$923 ($0.17/gallon) — Best premium under-sink
  8. Pentair Everpure H-1200: ~$2,050 ($0.37/gallon) — Commercial-grade quality
  9. ZeroWater pitcher: ~$4,160 ($0.75/gallon) — Maximum purity, maximum cost

Key Takeaways

  • Pitcher filters are only cheap upfront. Over 5 years, some pitcher systems cost more than under-sink RO due to frequent filter replacements.
  • Under-sink RO is the best value for serious filtration. The iSpring RCC7AK's 5-year cost ($558) is barely more than a budget pitcher system, while delivering dramatically better water quality.
  • Brita Elite saves money vs. Brita Standard. Despite costing more per filter, the Elite's 3x longer life makes it cheaper per gallon. It is the rare upgrade that actually saves you money.
  • ZeroWater is extremely expensive long-term. Great for specific applications (very high TDS water), but impractical for most households at $0.75 per gallon.
  • Any filter beats bottled water. Even the most expensive filter system costs less per gallon than the cheapest bottled water brand.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the cheapest water filter to own long-term?
The Amazon Basics pitcher with Amazon Basics Enhanced replacement filters is the cheapest overall system. The pitcher costs Under $25, and replacement filters cost Under $25 for a 3-pack (about $3.50 each). At 6 filters per year for a family of 4, that is roughly $21 per year in replacements after the initial $24 pitcher. Total 5-year cost: approximately $128. That is about $0.07 per gallon of filtered water.
Is a reverse osmosis system worth the investment?
For households with serious water quality issues (high TDS, lead, PFAS), absolutely. The iSpring RCC7AK costs $100–$250 upfront, but replacement filters cost only $50-$70 per year. Over 5 years, the total cost is approximately $450-$550 — comparable to a pitcher system that provides far less filtration. The cost per gallon drops below $0.05 over time, making RO the most cost-effective serious filtration option.
How does filtered water compare to bottled water cost?
Bottled water typically costs $0.50-$2.00 per gallon depending on the brand. A family of 4 consuming 3 gallons per day spends $550-$2,200 per year on bottled water. The most expensive filtration system in our analysis (Waterdrop G3P600) costs about $0.09 per gallon — 5-22x cheaper than bottled. The cheapest option (Amazon Basics pitcher) costs $0.07 per gallon — 7-28x cheaper.
Do RO systems cost more in water waste?
Yes, water waste adds to the cost. Traditional RO systems waste 3-4 gallons per filtered gallon, adding roughly $0.01-$0.03 per gallon at average US water rates ($0.004/gallon). Modern efficient systems like the Waterdrop G3P600 (2:1 ratio) waste less. For most households, the wastewater cost adds $10-$30 per year — noticeable but not significant compared to filter costs.
Which pitcher filter has the lowest cost per gallon?
The Amazon Basics Enhanced replacement filter at Under $25 for a 3-pack, with each filter rated at 40 gallons, costs about $0.09 per gallon. The Brita Elite at $25–$50 for a 2-pack, with each filter rated at 120 gallons, costs about $0.12 per gallon. Despite the higher upfront cost, the Brita Elite is competitive because of its longer filter life. ZeroWater is the most expensive at $0.60-$1.00 per gallon due to its very short filter life.
Should I factor in electricity costs for RO systems?
Tankless RO systems like the Waterdrop G3P600 and countertop RO systems like the Bluevua models require electricity for their pumps. The energy consumption is minimal — roughly $5-$15 per year. Tank-based systems like the iSpring RCC7AK use only water pressure (no electricity), making them the most economical to operate. Electricity costs are a minor factor in total cost of ownership.
How much does it cost to maintain a refrigerator water filter?
Refrigerator filter costs depend on OEM vs aftermarket. OEM GE XWFE filters cost $25–$50 every 6 months ($99/year). OEM everydrop Filter 1 costs $50–$100 every 6 months ($108/year). Aftermarket alternatives like the AQUACREST 6-pack at $16.88 bring the annual cost down to just $5.63 — an enormous savings. The trade-off is fewer NSF certifications.

Invest in the Right System

The cheapest filter to buy is not always the cheapest filter to own. Use the cost breakdowns above to find the system that matches both your water quality needs and your budget over time. For help choosing the right type, start with our Complete Buying Guide. If you are budget-constrained, see our Best Filters Under $50. And for full product rankings, visit our Best Countertop Filters and Best Under-Sink Filters roundups.

Related Guides

Best Water Filters Under $50

Budget-friendly filters that deliver real results.

How to Choose a Water Filter

Match the right filter to your needs and budget.

Water Filter Maintenance Guide

Proper maintenance extends filter life and saves money.

Best Under-Sink Filters

Our top picks for long-term value in permanent filtration.